Showing posts with label imitation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label imitation. Show all posts

Saturday, 26 August 2023

Note to self

Rational thought, followed by deliberate conscious intention, is such a weak tool for bringing about action - let alone change - that I have to carry instructions to myself on a cue card!

I doubt the below will mean anything to you, but then it’s not meant to!

(The more astute may realise some of these half sentences are cribs and at least one lifted in its entirety.)

Saturday, 9 April 2011

'..the best is yet to come...'

It was my intention when I started this blog a little over a year ago to have said everything I wanted to say about mental health by now. Yet I still have a mountain of half-written material. And I must go on, what’s to come is my best work, and builds on the foundations of everything posted so far. I guess I still have about a year to go (assuming my other responsibilities stay the same) before I can leave here, cross to my other blog Hunter-gatherer - the past in us ( http://hunter-gathers.blogspot.com/ ) and begin on the subject that really drives me - evolutionary anthropology. So, I thought I’d just write a short piece about where all the previous posts are leading to.

What is still to come, is first The Recovery Movement (part three); the final article on the Recovery approach looking at two local attempts to put it into practice. That should be followed by my completing an essay (about 6000 words) on my last experience of being an inpatient in 2005, a period for which I have complete medical, nursing, ambulance and police records. It’s working title is I Know, Because I Was There - health records and personal recall, two versions of a ‘psychotic’ episode. Once completed it can then be reformatted into three or four (not too long) blog posts. Following that is another essay for which I’ve allowed my myself 6000 words, and called Challenging Expertise - my misadventures in mental health education; which charts and reflects upon my experience of being a service user in education, being a service user undertaking training in mental health work, and on how academia (at all levels) trains it’s workforce and researches it’s subject. Hopefully it too will convert to three or four reasonable sized posts. This should be rapidly followed by ‘the thesis that never was’, Ways Of Being With - rethinking expertise in mental health. This was the research project which was rejected by a local university and caused me not to complete my M.Sc in Mental Health. It will run to about 12,000 words (half that already) but, minus the stuff I’ve written about before, it should be dividable into six post-sized chunks. It explores the wealth of tacit knowledge involved with being with people in mental distress, then offers a radically different (compared with current practice that is) way of thinking and behaving when trying to be an effective helper. In fact if offers a lot of ancient heuristics which are being re-emphasised as a result of the findings of neuroscience. Then comes The Sound Of Water - on the possibility of an ecotherapy. This piece is a critical exploration of the idea that there can be an ecopsychology and by extension, ecotherapy. Though many practicing green care claim that it amounts to ecotherapy, very little has been written or researched about it. It will also include an application of the principles of Ways Of Being With. Again another four or so posts. Finally Natural Mental Health, a post which asserts that there is such a thing as normal, or better still natural, mental and physical fitness (you can’t really separate mind and body) and that there is excellence in living, which can and should be emulated. After all, imitation is, what is special about human learning.

Needless to say these six projects (amounting to about twenty more posts) have been progressing in parallel for sometime (they need to, if they’re all to fit together!) The final piece should, at one and the same time, become the first post on the new blog about pre-agricultural ‘forms of life’ - how we have spent 95% of our real history as hunter-gatherers, and how that legacy is still with us.

Friday, 16 July 2010

Sex and mental health

The character and diversity of sexual relationships found amongst people in the mental health industry are much the same as in the wider world. This should surprise no one. Just as people often meet their future partners in the workplace, some relationships of enduring emotional and or sexual attachment have always existed - and will always exist - between clients, staff and carers.

However, even more than the neglect of client’s spiritual needs, mental health workers make no attempt to routinely address the problems their clients have in the conduct of sexual relationships. If you have had a useful and productive talk with a mental health worker about sexual concerns, then you are the exception. Most workers have a set of priorities for clients that place addressing sexual needs at the end of a very long list. Yet if the objective is to promote positive change; well, what does most to boost your self-confidence? What is one of the key motivations in life?

Much of what follows is obvious, but needs to be spelt-out, for one should never underestimate the capacity of mental health services to take the commonplace and complicate it with the dead-hand of specialist trainers, rules of ‘best practice’, and endless committees obstructing by arguing about appropriateness. I made the assumption many decades ago that when it came to the treatment of mental distress, I would come across those people with the best communication skills - how innocent of me!

(I’m reminded of the old story of the sociologist who wants to study prostitution spending years raising a grant of tens of thousands of pounds, hiring assistants to find and survey a random sample - when all he needed to do was take a train to the city of his choice, go to the first taxi on the rank, and tell the cabbie to drive him around for an hour. He might not even have had to ‘frame a question’ at all!)

The central problem for most clients is that they do not see successful personal and sexual relationships around them in their everyday lives - they have nothing to learn from, to model or imitate. Even the conversational conventions between men and women, whether partners or not, are often unobserved because clients spend so little time in ordinary social spaces. Equally within organised activities provided by mental health services, it is very rare to find a couple working together.

A person in mental distress is pre-occupied with self, and needs to let go of that a little before the reciprocity required in normal relationships can be ‘seen’. Equally they often don’t understand how relationships have to be made and negotiated, how giving your partner what they want, will get you what you want. Users of services often believe that ‘romance’ happens by chance and then proceeds in some automatic or natural way. They don’t know how much there is to learn and to practice in order to acquire social and physical skill.

Even more than the rest of humanity they have lived vicariously, but without trying to imitate and test, so retain the expectations of Hollywood and the media’s imagined world of celebrity - the dramatic contrasts between idealised romantic love, and varieties of extreme dysfunction. So, whilst it is true to say all clients have experienced the real world as traumatic in some way, often in close relationships, they may at one and the same time have an expectation of ‘more of the same’ coupled with - inevitably - unrealistic expectations of how different and successful the situation of others is. Like everyone else they grew-up believing what they witnessed in childhood was the norm and however well educated now, may still expect the same, sometimes playing-out a self-fulfilling prophecy. But in addition have a profoundly distorted fantasy as to what happiness, fulfilment, contentment or excitement are, or can be.

Most clients who are in the system for many years experience long periods of celibacy punctuated by a series of short, mutually unsatisfactory relationships most of which occur with other clients. As we know, what attracts people are perceived points of similarity, for those who’s social world is so restricted, it is often clients with similar problems who find each other - they share the same strengths, but also the same weaknesses. In such situations little that is new can be learnt - other than how to move in ever decreasing circles.

To achieve any kind of ‘recovery’ requires teaching in the possibilities of intimacy. And opportunities are forever being lost due to the fear and timidity of workers or their managers. A classic example is the so called ‘predatory male’ patient on a hospital ward. Imagine the following scenario. Staff notice a male patient taking a particular interest in a female member of staff; if she is noticeably younger than him and relatively inexperienced, alarm bells will ring. The woman concerned will report that she has noticed his attention because it does not lead to an ordinary two-way interaction, he is overtly interested but stand-offish, not demanding nor conversational, he just always seems to be around, which makes her uneasy. The behaviour is interpreted by staff as inappropriate and as possibly indicative of some covert sexual intent. The action taken is to separate the two people. The male patient then participates less in the activity of the ward, becomes less cooperative or positively hostile. This is seen as confirmation that the staff’s interpretation of the situation was correct and the right decision made.

Wrong. The male patient may well be less cooperative, he’s been rejected again. The staff reaction may well create more extreme behaviour in the future. The male patient looks menacing and predatory because of his incompetence, he’s never had the chance to learn the skills of normal social interaction, how to approach and begin to build an intimate relationship. A major opportunity is lost because the female member of staff is the person he feels most attracted by or attached to - he is motivated by her. In other words, she is the person in the most powerful position to affect change in him! She, whatever her job or status, should be the one to work with him. If the woman is confident enough in her sexuality, then she can enter into a contract with him, which stated crudely would say; you can’t have me, but we can spend a certain number of hours together. We can hang-around so you can get comfortable being around women, and I’ll teach you what a woman like me, wants and expects in a relationship - I’ll show you how to approach a woman like me.

Real outcomes have to be made, and in specific social situations; aggression, violence and abuse arise - like fun, happiness and contentment - as a result of the interaction between people. No one person is ever the sole cause of anything. Just as the way someone is treated in the first few hours of contact with mental health services may set the pattern for years to come, anyone who is trapped or confined by others will, sooner or later lash-out. But equally someone who is confident but non-threatening, can begin the process of change in others.

Monday, 21 June 2010

Stephen Fry And I - self-stigmatisation?

Acquiring the DVD of Stephen Fry's two part documentary The Secret Life of a Manic Depressive has caused me to reflect on how differently I now feel about mental health services, Stephen, and myself - 5 years on from when the programmes were made.

Stephen and I go back a long way. I've often relied upon him for a bit of 'vicarious living', although of course we have never met. We seem similar in many ways (apart from the sexuality that is - I consider myself 95% straight).

Everyone enjoys some vicarious living, and since the rise of Hollywood in the 1930's, probably more so in our time than in previous eras. But the more socially isolated one is - the more one lives in fantasy with little 'reality checking', and the more one depends upon it for the sense of intimacy and belonging one would normally get face to face. Stated another way, those with a diagnosis or label of  mental illness depend on fantasy more than others.

So having imaged for many years that Stephen and I had a temperamental connection, the revelations in the two documentaries came as no surprise. But my attitude on first viewing was very different to the one I have now. Then I was happy to describe myself as Bipolar, the label had explanatory value for me. Indeed the only reason to accept a diagnosis should be if it has some practical use value to you; if it explains something about you to yourself, making it easier to live with yourself; if it gives you access to useful help, or helpers; if it helps you to act differently, or to let you get things you want but don’t already have.

Also at that time I believed mental health services still had some useful expertise I could acquire (even though by that stage I'd been a service user - off and on - for 18 years) Equally, alongside 'Bipolar' explaining something to me about myself, when I found some supposed characteristic of the Bipolar person I'd not previously known about, I still gave serious thought to the possibility that I must have missed something more about myself. I was well on the way to becoming the next Kay Redfield Jameson.

Why do we hang-on to beliefs, routines, habits which appear illogical and sometimes positively self-destructive? Because they appear safer than the alternative. All change (good or bad) is at first experienced as stressful (occasionally terrifying). Others will be reassuring and tell you of the benefits of change, but this of course counts for nothing! Any change requires acting before we really feel competent to do so.

Having learnt something of the above much has changed in my life over the last five years. I have no 'symptoms' so cannot legitimately use the label, my identity is based upon my actual activities and the social contacts I make, my explanations of myself come from evolutionary biology and neuroscience (natural variation in the limbic system and as a consequence a lot of dodgy learning) and not from psychiatry or clinical psychology. But as I get better and happier, the more angry I become about the pathetic record of mental health services, past and present. However, I still take one prescription drug - having been on one mood stabilizer or another for 17 years, it gives me a certain minimal status and some entitlements in the face of unemploy-ability!

And Stephen? Well, I still follow his antics and enjoy his writing - he persists in making me laugh. I can see that his giving-up smoking and taking more physical exercise are hugely beneficial. But it now seems crazy for him to use an intense work schedule as therapy - a way of staying one step ahead of depression rather than stopping and confronting it. It is not until we give ourselves permission to relax that you can feel and let go of pain. He remains a man uncomfortable in his own body - especially in those moments of verbal linguistic magic. And that takes us to the core fear of the supposed Bipolar person - that recovery, change, or just stopping to relax and let go, means an end to creativity. IT'S A MYTH. Indeed, the ability to let go brings greater spontaneous creation. Stephen declares he must shut himself away in order to write, even to the extent of keeping the curtains drawn to shut out the rising sun. Tish and pish I say my fluffy friend, raise your eyes to the horizon, the answers come from being at home in the outside world.

For more on labelling ourselves, see my February post Goffman and Becker; stigma and labelling.

Stephen's website is at; http://www.stephenfry.com/
The DVD is available at Amazon; http://www.amazon.co.uk/Stephen-Frys-Secret-Manic-Depressive/dp/B002XT38GO/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&s=dvd&qid=1277016760&sr=1-2

Sunday, 13 June 2010

Walking Through Life - how mental distress is caught and taught

As a child you watched how parents or siblings walked and then you began to copy them. So it was with everything else you learnt, as peers and other adults entered your environment. Experience and learning are inseparable. The more you practice existing skills, the more you try to reproduce today, the world as it was yesterday. All learning consists of first imitating (copying or modelling) how others behave, then repeated practice (trial and error) - both mentally and physically - until you gain a skill. All behaviours are habits. And the only way to overcome an unwanted habit is to copy a better one from someone else. We are social animals with a social brain.

At some point you learnt to walk down the street and avoid eye contact with someone (the invitation to normal social interaction), if that became a habit, not just towards those you disliked for a reason, but a practice applied to the whole social world of others you acquired a mental 'illness'. The classic way of avoiding eye contact is to look down and away (a gesture normally reserved for the occasional experience of shame), but if you stare at the pavement for a lifetime - rather than naturally allowing the eyes to return to the horizon giving an automatic upright posture - then you become a physical cripple because of your social isolation.

Another form of isolation is when we look through people, being physically present but mentally somewhere else. But that leaves the person terribly exposed, you can't do two things at once - fantasise and be in the present moment. Very quickly others notice that your speech simply doesn't fit the situation. The so-called 'psychotic' person follows an erratic path and easily becomes disorientated because they are disorganised. Eventually, they too will look down and away.

Sometimes people come to believe that hanging-on to familiar, habitual, well understood, fears will keep them safe, not just from occasional real physical danger, but from other anxieties in everyday living. The desire to be in control too much - causes more isolation from others. But when you make eye contact with others, when you operate your body in the same way as someone else, you begin to have the same kinds of thoughts (though the content may be different). The desire to belong, which is in all of us, is rewarded.

(See previous posts on meditation, and physical therapy for the 'up' side of the story. The acquisition of new social skills and better habits will be discussed in future posts).

Saturday, 27 March 2010

Acceptance is the hardest 'skill' to learn

It’s a skill because it doesn’t come naturally.

I once asked a friend of mine who is a senior mental health worker, and almost universally liked by everyone: ‘Isn’t the idea of “unconditional positive regard” totally unrealistic - it implies you can like anyone who walks through the door?’ He then claimed that he did like almost every client. I think he was fooling himself, and what he meant with the benefit of hindsight, was that he came to like almost every client - that the more he understood someone the more he liked them.

Carl Rogers started it when he asserted the possibility of unconditional positive regard towards others, built on the idea of accepting oneself:

‘I find I am more effective when I can listen acceptantly to myself, and can be myself.’ (Roger 1967:17)

‘…the curious paradox is that when I accept myself as I am, then I change.’

‘If I can accept the fact that I am annoyed at or bored with this client or this student, then I am also much more likely to be able to accept his feelings in response.’ (p.18)

‘I have found it highly rewarding when I can accept another person.’ (p.20)

The post-war humanist perspective in psychology lost touch with the biology of the human animal - as indeed did the cognitive revolution that followed it. Anxiety should rise when meeting strangers or outsiders, they are a potential threat, you should be cautiously testing each other. We do have very strong first impressions; it is called intuition, and relies on fast emotional responses - it is what keeps us alive. The only question on first meeting someone is: ‘Do I feel safe with this person?’ So the effective helper knows that they must appear safe and non-threatening, but what if you don‘t feel that? We can all be aggressive and violent, if we need to be. It’s not a matter of accepting people as they are, it’s about creating useful encounters where mutual learning can take place and that depends on establishing a relationship of trust. Sometimes it can happen very fast if there is a mutual liking, if there isn’t then it will never happen.

When asked, people self-report that what makes the best first impression is a sense of ‘warmth’ and ‘competence’ in the other person ( www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=mixed-impressions ), but I think what they really mean is someone who is non-threatening and can deliver something they need. Because first impressions are emotional responses they have very little to do with what is actually said, more with how it is said and the rest of our non-verbal behaviour. We trust those emotions displayed through facial expression much more than the accepting words.

The client is present because they know there is something wrong with them, whether they state it or not, something that stops them functioning in the social world as they would wish. That is why they are seeking help, they’re not looking for acceptance but action, on the assumption that they are meeting with someone with skills and expertise.

But what of Rogers’ underlying point that accepting oneself and others as we are now, is in some sense a precondition of change? Wrong. The preconditions are self-awareness and a willingness to learn new things! And the speed at which it can be done depends on the rapport between the people involved.

One barrier to rapport (effective communication) is the myth that the helper can be accepting as part of their professional role, setting aside their personal feelings. This is obviously ridiculous because feelings always leak-out through facial expression and tone of voice. This first becomes apparent when a prospective helper is still a student and at some point becomes aware of a conflict between their developing intellectual understanding and their emotional response in a given situation. The trick is integrating the two. If I believe in the knowledge I have acquired then I must live that way, the mistake is thinking that one is work and the other a private concern. The answer comes in two parts, firstly in terms of organisation there has to be proper team working - teams purposefully constructed of different kinds of people with different skills, hence giving the client choice!

Secondly, any kind of therapy is the learning of new social and psychological skills and the helper is the model. Acceptance is the skill of tolerating what we cannot change. Now if either or both, client and worker have it in their heads that the client is suffering an illness for which there is no cure… Even the Recovery approach leaves the medical model in place, telling the client to expect occasional relapse. So often both client and worker set each other up to fail. But if your model is one of adaptation in a particular social environment you have two choices, neither of which require acceptance of anything. Either you change yourself (learn new skills) to fit the environment you find yourself in, or you move on and live in a new environment.

It is a belief in people‘s lack of capacity to change which makes acceptance, so unnatural as it is, such a hard skill to learn - requiring decades of practice by the helper!

(See also my post, The ‘therapeutic relationship’ explained - Jan 2010)

Rogers, C (1967) On Becoming a Person: A Therapist’s View of Psychotherapy (Constable: London)

Sunday, 21 February 2010

John Clare - from the Northampton Asylum

They, have never thought to lay a pathway from the hospital entrance to where the pavement ends on the edge of our town. If you do not have a car, and generally we don’t, and given the irregular bus service - then you must for a short distance walk along the main road. The hospital has changed its purpose over the years, today if you are a patient there it usually means you are coming to the end of a prison sentence, but receiving treatment because you have a mental disorder. If you are driving along the road and are frightened by a menacing male figure; well, remember he looks ragged because he has so little to his name, is walking because he has no money, is scared by the amount of traffic (that is you) and shocked by the outside world which he hasn’t felt, unaccompanied and for himself, for - how long?

When I have business at the hospital I always walk. Those who seek to ‘involve’ me always offer a lift, I refuse saying it’s just up the road. In fact it is a half hour walk at a leisurely pace - and it has to be that way. Those workers who organise us, talk of ‘journeys’ to a recovery, or care ‘pathways’ - I prefer something more grounded in the reality of the material world and with a real history. On that journey I inevitably think of the times in my ‘career’ as a mental patient when I have just had to be outside, have used walking as an attempt to clear my mind. I often think of the poet John Clare’s fifty mile walk home, over the best part of two days and a night, having escaped from his first confinement, and who, were he alive today, might well have had the same diagnosis as myself (Bipolar Affective Disorder) - and of course have found a large part of his pathway occupied by the A1! The real journey to the hospital has only one ‘staging post’ and that is the wooden bus shelter, which survives - just. There I pause, to make that adjustment you must make when passing from your own world to that of workers and clients interacting with each other. I roll a cigarette, look for any additions to the graffiti (a kind of testimony) and think about the problem every client has - the inability to explain oneself to others.

John Clare (1793-1864) was a small farmer who briefly found fame in the 19th century, becoming known as ‘the peasant poet’ but was then socially excluded when he began to experience mental health problems. He spent the last 20 years of his life confined in the Northampton County Asylum but was able from time to time to continue writing poems, one of which was ‘I Am’;

‘I am! Yet what I am who cares, or knows?
My friends forsake me like a memory lost.
I am the self-consumer of my woes;
They rise and vanish, an obvious host,
Shadows of life, whose very soul is lost.
And yet I am - I live - though I am toss’d

Into the nothingness of scorn and noise,
Into the living sea of waking dream,
Where there is neither sense of life, nor joys,
But the huge shipwreck of my own esteem
And all that’s dear. Even those I loved the best
Are strange - nay, they are stranger than the rest.

I long for scenes where man has never trod -
For scenes where woman never smiled or wept -
There to abide with my Creator, God,
And sleep as I in childhood sweetly slept,
Full of high thoughts, unborn. So let me lie, -
The grass below; above, the vaulted sky.’

Detail from photo of the  Northampton Asylum grounds as they are today via St. Andrews Healthcare

Forty years after his death however, he did achieve a kind of inclusion, validation and immortality through the efforts of a legendary teacher Arthur Quiller-Couch who included the poem in the first edition of the Oxford Book of English Verse. Quiller-Couch (known to all as Q) taught at Cambridge University and in the early 1930’s was personal tutor to one Alistair Cooke who then went on, through his radio broadcasts (Letter From America 1946-2003) to give several generations in the UK their first taste of America. He pioneered ‘writing for talking’ in which the broadcaster speaks personally and directly to what he imagines is just one person!

In the late 1930’s a young women from Philadelphia made her way to New York in the hope of becoming a playwright. It would be thirty years before she found success, but she educated herself at various public libraries and discovered there Q’s writing on modern language and literature. Indeed one of her books is entitled Q’s legacy, alas not as widely read as her second book which simply contained her correspondence with a secondhand book dealer in London’s Charing Cross Road. Helene Hanff wrote short, direct and extremely powerful letters to Frank Doel, which would not look out of place today on any social networking site.

From 1975 until his death a couple of years ago, John Mortimer created in fiction a great comic hero. Horace Rumpole, defending barrister, who rejects status and money, in order to uphold the rights of ordinary citizens. He’s ridiculed by the people around him, but always comes out fighting using humour as a weapon. Famously he often quotes from his bedtime reading - Q’s anthology. He has a soft leather bound copy, printed on India paper with gold leaf around the edges, alas my copy has only a cardboard cover - but it’s still just the right size to slip into a pocket when out and about searching for some grass to lie on beneath that vaulted sky.

(And of course, all the above is what is meant by the vertical transmission of memes!)

Bate, J (2003) John Clare: A Biography Picador: London
Quiller-Couch, A. T ed. (1906) The Oxford Book Of English Verse 1250-1900 Clarendon Press: Oxford

Saturday, 30 January 2010

It's the company you keep! (updated 2014)

(Christakis and Fowler 2008)
I've been directing people to the short article below since it first appeared on the Edge.org site almost two years ago. On the surface it's just a small investigation of a few hundred of the early student users of facebook - but give it some thought and a second read and the implications are enormous. Much of my writing on this blog insists that the real world, along with the virtual one, is like the article describes. Mental distress is made and unmade everyday through our interaction with others. When it persists for long periods we become progressively more isolated. Mapping social networks suggest how such a process works.

Friday, 29 January 2010

The 'therapeutic relationship' explained


...or rather, how it comes about that often the relationships between mental health workers and their clients aren’t beneficial to either party.

We become clients of mental health services because we find it impossible to maintain happy social relationships - we may never have experienced them, or experienced trauma when they breakdown, or had difficulties in making new ones.

We then enter a system of care which doesn’t offer us ordinary relationships, or training in how to conduct and maintain them, but instead involves a form of social interaction based on the worker playing out two roles; that of bureaucrat on the one hand, and counsellor on the other.

Firstly, there is always the aspect of a ‘paid friendship’, so you can never be sure of the genuineness of the worker, their feelings about you are always hidden to a greater or lesser extent. They are not choosing to be with us. What are we to conclude when we see a mismatch between what they say and what they display non-verbally? They are of course observing the same in us, but usually concluding it’s an aspect of our character, rather than a reflection of their behaviour!

If the relationship should turn out to be a good one it is quickly terminated by the worker; if it is less successful it may persist for decades.

We usually meet them at a time and place of their choosing, often in a specially designated building isolated from normal social life. This is presented as an aspect of confidentiality and freedom to disclose. However, whilst the location often feels familiar and safe to the worker, for us it may be quite the opposite.

Given the isolating nature of mental distress, and the fact that the worker has many other clients, they are almost always (for good or bad) more important in our lives than we are in their's.

They assess us, and even if they accept our conception of our problems, even if we are able to assert our rights and entitlements, they remain the gatekeepers to care. We are promised confidentiality, but also told that when they deem it necessary they will consult others.

We are told the encounter is our space, ours to control or direct. Yet because they do not self-disclose - we are expected to talk about the most intimate, and therefore most difficult to articulate, aspects of our lives to someone who always remains a stranger.

Since the assumption is that we are the ones who bring our problems to the encounter, what is actually happening in the room is either ignored or grossly misinterpreted because of an unconsidered factor - what years of meeting everyday with a variety of people in mental distress has done to the health and perceptions of the worker! (Remember, they get their supervision from even more experienced workers).

Normal, healthy encounters are as follows. We meet as strangers, often have strong first impressions of like or dislike, intuitions of threat or safety (which we ought to follow, leaving immediately if necessary). It is only after some time that we reveal confidences, when some trust has been established based on both parties willingness to mirror and match the other with minor disclosures about themselves. Equality and reciprocity are built-in to normal social encounters. We are attracted by points of similarity between ourselves and the other person. Friendship may or may not follow. If it does, then it becomes appropriate to give advice or instruct. You earn the right to say - ‘don’t do that, I know what happened last time, even if you have forgotten’. When on the receiving end, you may not like what is being said, but by now you have undeniable evidence that the person cares about your wellbeing. And of course, all this time you have been meeting at a time and place negotiated between yourselves.

So how can these abnormal encounters with workers actually improve practical opportunities for more and better social interaction in the real world? You walk away from a meeting with a mental health professional and within a few hours, like all encounters, you remember little of what was said rather the atmosphere that was created. We leave with a feeling of whether it was a good or bad experience. But we should go further and ask ourselves, have I learnt something practical today which will make it easier to get up tomorrow?

Tuesday, 26 January 2010

Online meditation and Wisdom2.0



Think of the Web as an add-on to your brain. When you combine it’s increasing connectivity with the memetic selection of searching you have a partial reflection of how the mind works. What was once a very weak analogy between the brain and computers, is becoming stronger.


Whether your influence over the domain in which selection takes place is greater than you have in your social environment is unclear - it appears that way, but it could be an illusion. However the dangers of too greater specialisation, leading to extreme dependence on a particular environment are very real. The more precisely you search and the more limited your connections, the more you exclude and put blinkers on yourself. Another form of emotional and cognitive isolation.


Equally the stressors in the virtual world often mirror those in the physical one. The idea of applying meditation techniques to the way we use computers and the internet has been taken up by Soren Gordhamer in his book Wisdom2.0
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Wisdom-2-0-Creative-Constantly-Connected/dp/0061651516/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1264459010&sr=1-1 Later this year there will be a Wisdom2.0 conference http://www.wisdom2conference.com/

Soren writes columns for The Huffington Post
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/soren-gordhamer and Mashable.com http://mashable.com/author/soren-gordhamer/

Saturday, 16 January 2010

An evolutionary approach to mental health


What follows is a temporary, but necessary diversion into ‘grand theory’. Necessary, because any approach to mental health that isn’t compatible with a theory of human behaviour in general doesn’t stand a chance. (Those stuck in the insular world of psychiatry and clinical psychology please note). I’ve included references this time, just to give pause to those tempted to come down on me ‘like a ton of bricks’!

I have an evolving definition and explanation for what mental distress (disorder or illness, mild or severe) is. It shows itself as a misplaced fear of others. Personal relationships breakdown, followed by an inability to form and maintain new ones. The sufferer becomes progressively more emotionally and cognitively isolated (which may or may not involve physical isolation too).

Madness results from our failure to constantly update and modify the mental map of the world we have in our brain. If we do not ‘test’ our predictions, beliefs, dreams, thoughts, internal dialogue, fantasies, hypotheses, plans, ideas about how the world is, and what the people within it think and feel, our map becomes rapidly out of date. If we act with an out of date model of the world - we will look mad to others, and they will treat us as mad. If others don’t share a large part of our model of reality we are emotionally and cognitively isolated. Though none of us ‘see’ the world as it really is, we all rely on making a more or less accurate map; by sharing we come to have a more complete understanding than we could ever achieve alone. The ability to doubt and live with uncertainty, and hence know that we must constantly test our vision of the world - is sanity. To control and fix our view is the first step on the road to disaster. And of course the only way to maintain an unchanging outlook is to isolate oneself from any evidence that might contradict it. If we fail to observe (insufficient data) or misinterpret (wrong theory) then the map becomes more out of date. If our prediction disagrees with the experiment it is wrong. An unmodified and out of date model of the world is one where our thoughts and feelings are anchored in the past, hence our predictions of the future may be hopelessly wrong. Mental disorder is emotional and cognitive isolation to varying degrees.


Emotional reactions always come first, from what our five senses are telling us in the present moment, only afterwards do we attach thoughts. If we attach thoughts that come from the past, then we are operating with an out of date model of the world. So often we are not aware of what, in the present moment is ‘cueing’ our emotions and reproducing redundant thoughts. It is natural to be in a meditative state and to focus on the present moment. When the mind drifts away the discipline is to learn to let go, again and again. It is the opposite of taking control. It is about allowing decisions to make themselves, of not worrying about an unknowable future and refusing to get involved in hopes and expectations. The goal should be greater mental awareness of others, at the same time as being more physically relaxed. A full-time activity done with the eyes open. Meditation is not a set of skills that once acquired, can be called on at leisure; for one’s inability to operate in the world, based on the learning made in past relationships, will always return unless such skills are continuously practiced. Unwanted emotions and thoughts from the past will always ‘crash-in’ - meditation is a continuous process of letting go. The myth of self-control leads most to imagine that without it, mayhem and moral collapse will ensue. In practice, the need to manage others falls away and you become a better companion!

The best introduction to meditation I have come across, as a way of operating throughout the day, is to be found in Harrison (1994), and can be read along with his articles on how the core skills have been extracted from their religious context (Harrison 2005-). Sue Blackmore goes further, much further, by placed meditation techniques in the context of human cultural and biological evolution, and how we have evolved the very idea of a ‘self’ (Blackmore 2000:219-246). It’s possible to move towards a resolution of the contradictions of modern life, and the mental distress they give rise to, by developing both an evolutionary perspective and by being aware of the promise of social neuroscience (deCharms 2008, Goleman 2007, Ramachandran 2009). If you view daily life as evolution by natural selection, from minute to minute as well as on a timescale of the last 180,000 years (since we became homo sapiens with our full range of mental capabilities and capacities), see the biological and social as evolving in parallel and feeding back on each other (though at very different rates), then other kinds of questions and explanations suggest themselves (Oppenheimer 2004, Dawkins 1989, Blackmore 2000, Stevens & Price 2000, Nesse & Williams 1996, Nesse 2006).


We have lived out ninety-five per cent of our history as hunter-gathers, moving through and living from the environment. The last eight to ten thousand years, since we have sought to transform the environment (with the invention of agriculture, ideas of ownership and permanent settlement), has been an exceptional, perverse, untypical and abnormal period. Our point of reference for mental wellbeing should be the pre-agricultural world, where we evolved to be nomadic, as part of groups (‘bands’) of no more than about one hundred and thirty people, consisting of relatively close genetic relatives. You cannot ‘know’, as in feel an emotional attachment for, more than about that number of people.

Empathy (the ability to feel what others feel) and a ‘theory of mind’ (knowing how others think) derive from humans almost unique ability to imitate using the ‘mirror neurons’ of the brain, and give the capability to identify with, and be accepted by your group! (Blackmore 2000, Ramachandran 2000, 2003:97-131, 2006, 2007, 2009) If these abilities are blocked by life experience, then you become isolated from the people you are genetically most attached and attracted to. The last eight to ten thousand years has seen the construction of a world containing mental illness. And the culmination is the development of mental health workers, with the normal human capacities, who then try to empathise and share the ‘theory of mind’ of the unhealthy! This leads to the maintenance or reproduction of mental distress. Therapists should be leaders, mentors and role models to whom a client can apprentice themselves, and should not try to connect or catch the habits of the ill. As clients we must imitate the mentally healthy. Three out of four people don’t have a mental health problem during their life times.

And it’s not ‘faulty’ genes either, it is because we did our early learning with very close genetic relatives to whom we are automatically attached. Problems arise as a result of conflicts between the quality of our learning and our attachment to the person from whom we learnt. If you were separated from your close genetic relatives, your learning may well have been exceptional, but your life may become a search for those you are instinctively attached to. Equally you may search the world in vain for a ‘soul mate’, because it is so unlikely in modern society that you will ever meet that person, from the edge of your natural ‘group’, with whom you have a relatively close genetic attraction. It never was nature or nurture - but the ways in which your personal learning, your own cultural evolution, conflicted with the demands of your own biology. Your genes will determine to whom you are attached and attracted to, but it is with your learning that mental disorder is created and maintained.

References 
Blackmore, S (2000) The Meme Machine Oxford University: Oxford
Dawkins, R (1989) The Selfish Gene Oxford University: Oxford
deCharms, C (2008) Christopher deCharms looks inside the brain TED conference presentation Feb 2008



Goleman, D (2007) Social Intelligence: The New Science of Human Relationships Arrow: London
Harrison, E (1994) Teach Yourself To Meditate Piatkus: London
Harrison, E (2005-) articles for Nova Magazine available at
http://www.perthmeditationcentre.com.au/articles/index.htm [10.1.10]
Nesse, R.M (2006) response to the ‘2005 Edge Question’ in Brockman, J (ed.) What We Believe But Cannot Prove Pocket: London
Nesse, R.M and Williams, G.C (1996) Evolution and Healing: The New Science of Darwinian Healing Phoenix: London
Oppenheimer, S (2004) Out Of Eden: The peopling of the world Robinson: London
Ramachandran, V. S (2000) MIRROR NEURONS and imitation learning as the driving force behind “the great leap forward” in human evolution
http://www.edge.org/3rd_culture/ramachandran/ramachandran_p1.html [19.7.08]
Ramachandran, V. S (2003) The Emerging Mind Profile/BBC: London
Ramachandran, V. S (2006) ‘Mirror Neurons And The Brain In The Vat’ response to the 2006 Edge Question at;
http://www.edge.org/3rd_culture/ramachandran06/ramachandran06_index.html [3.6.09]
Ramachandran, V. S (2007) Self Awareness: The Last Frontier
http://www.edge.org/3rd_culture/rama08/rama08_index.html [6.1.09]
Ramachandran, V. S (2009) The neurons that shape civilisation TED conference presentation.


Stephens, A and Price, J (2000) Evolutionary Psychiatry: A new beginning Routledge: London