![]() |
| New header photo 2019 (photo by Nick Hewling) |
Rethinking expertise in mental health (evolutionary & social neuroscience, nonverbals, embodied cognition, emotionAI, psychological skill, social craftsmanship.)
Showing posts with label embodied cognition. Show all posts
Showing posts with label embodied cognition. Show all posts
Tuesday, 16 April 2019
Where my head is at now
For my most recent mental health writing see Natural Mental Health. Everything else promised on this site is coming, and more besides, eventually!
Tuesday, 14 October 2014
The Recovery Movement (part three)
What
looks and feels radical to those attempting to bring about change from within
an organisation often appears to outsiders as the mildest of reforms. As a
general rule, groups - which share a collective self-interest - do not correct
errors and the world of mental health is no exception. Groups self-perpetuate
until external pressures cause them to collapse.
This
post looks at Recovery in practice, first at what workers using the approach
actually do, and secondly at how services have sort to reorganise themselves.
In my local area I was on the receiving end, as a client, of two attempts aimed
at introducing Recovery focused care; one a largely bottom-up and partially
successful community movement, the other a top-down formal reorganisation by an
NHS Trust which made very faltering progress.
This
post on the Recovery movement should be read in conjunction with part one
(January 2010) and part two (November 2010).
From
2005 onwards, the Community Care Trust (CCT) began to adopt a Recovery approach and its
employees tentatively began to change their attitudes, if not at first their
actual behaviour. They signed-up to the national Support, Time and Recovery
Worker programme (STR or STaR) and during 2007-8 I undertook some STR training
too.
From
STR Worker to Recovery Coach
For
a brief description of the STR role go to NHS Careers. For more detailed
accounts see Huxley et al (2006) and the National STR Handbook (Hope 2008).
Before
the national programme ended approximately 400 people within the county of
Devon had received some basic STR or other form of Recovery training. At the
time the Community Care Trust employed the equivalent of 70 full-time staff
with a mix of STR and mental nurse training. Later an additional internal
programme of training in ‘recovery coaching’ was added. I was a client of CCT
between 1999 and mid-2007 and retain close links with some of the staff and
many of the clients. Today a few workers appear to pursue the Recovery approach
in the fullest sense envisaged by Shepherd et al (2008) and Slade (2009),
others barely at all - but they all speak the language of Recovery!
Huxley
et al (2006) in describing what his research subjects did, provides a useful
summary of the STR role as originally conceived.
‘..STR
workers achieve [..] through engaging in practical and emotional support to
increase people’s participation in daily life through accessing further
education and training, obtaining and holding down a job, participating in
leisure activities, coping with personal financial matters, or finding their
way through the welfare and health systems. One of the effective ways that STR
workers achieve these ends is, by dint of their maturity and personal
experience, teaching the service user to do practical things for themselves, so
they have the confidence to go and do it in the future.’ (para.3.2 p.9)
‘The
STR worker establishes (where appropriate) a pattern of activity, first working
for service users and then with service users…This leads to situations where
service users are ready, and/or want support with, and/or teaching of,
practical skills. This in turn leads to increased social skills and/or
activities which lead to independence and then greater interdependence with
other people.’ (para.3.3 p.10)
During
the time I’ve been able to observe CCT workers, the focus of support has
shifted away from the practical and interventionist, towards an emphasis (as
highlight in part two) on the idea of a non-directive worker, and a
self-managing client. (Workers remain particularly sensitive to how the
prescriptive nature of pre-Recovery ‘therapeutic’ interventions often appeared
to add to the problems faced by their clients.) Whilst STR practitioners are
confident of the effectiveness - plus the political, moral and ethical
appropriateness of their work - nonetheless they have great difficulty in
articulating their approach. They have problems in describing their one to one
interactions with the users of services; how they do what they do, from whom
they have learnt what they do, and what is effective in a given situation.
Equally, clients often cannot describe what ‘makes a difference’ to the
resolution of a crises. So although comfortable with the language of Recovery,
developed over more than twenty years, which most workers claim they apply in
practice, they seem unable to demonstrate its meaning in action.
The
test of any approach of course must be how far its values and ethos are embodied in the way its practitioners
actually behave. The Recovery workers I’ve met, like many occupational groups
in health and social care, play down or sometimes actively avoid interpersonal
skills training and any attempt to modify their own non-verbal communication.
Instead there is a huge bias towards explicit cognitive tools, especially
language use, which is presumed to lead to change.
My
abiding image is of an incongruence between the content of what is spoken by
workers and their body language (tone of voice, gestures, facial expression,
eye and head movement, posture and body movement). Nonverbally there is always
an urgency to empathise (feel what another person is feeling), not just to
establish an initial connection or rapport, but as a regular strategy - which
too often ends up with them mirroring the disconnectedness between emotion and
reason displayed by the client!
The
principal tools used by the Recovery worker today are; the Wellness Recovery
Action Plan (WRAP), personal stories, mindfulness, formalised peer support,
traditional non-directive counselling plus some group social activities.
However the emotional content of what Recovery workers do as expressed through
their body language remains not only tacit, but almost entirely unexamined. Yet,
workers put a premium on genuineness and sometimes claim not to be playing any
role at all other than being themselves. They also recoil at the idea that they
should teach, model or demonstrate any desired or more effective behaviour for
a client to follow. They believe they should and can work with almost anyone
who walks through the door. Equally, they feel that if only they can escape the
organisational constraints placed upon them, and just be themselves, then that
in itself is therapeutic for the client. They have an extremely ambiguous
relationship with their own training, believing that they can embody the values
and attitudes of Recovery without having practiced anything other than making
verbal affirmations of their approach.
This
can be a disaster for the client, who is desperate for practical help from
someone with whom they feel physically and emotionally safe, and from whom they
can gain confidence. Still today, workers often appear to want to climb into
the ditch with the client, empathising beyond establishing a connection (which
at most takes a few minutes), and help through reason and rational talk, whilst
their bodies display something other than the social competency and lack of
fear that their client craves.
When
assessing themselves workers ask the client to self-report using written
questionnaires which - in contrast to their claims about practice - are highly
directive, designed and targeted at what they presume to be the priorities and
concerns of clients. There is a tendency to drop the word Recovery into any and
all questions, as in: ‘How has such-and-such contributed to your Recovery?’
They seem to lack awareness of a loaded question, of when they do lead, leaving
one sceptical of their claim that they know how not to in practice!
Organisational
Recovery
The
Recovery approach began as a bottom-up community movement gradually seeping
into policy through word of mouth. In the case of CCT it began in an organic
way before becoming systemised, however as it was adopted as policy by the NHS
(Shepherd et al 2008, Slade 2009), a much more top-down, designed approach was
taken.
Traditional
occupational groups such as mental health nurses, psychiatrists, occupational
therapists, social workers and others have been asked to ‘unlearn’ or ‘let go’
of established professionalised practice (SCMH 2009).
In
my local area the principal statuary provider, Devon Partnership NHS Trust (DPT) adopted Recovery focused care in the context of trying to move workers
from being highly bureaucratised helpers and administrators to networking
coaches. Many responded as if this was an attempt to deskill them. Yet this
occurred in the context of community psychiatric nurses spending about fifty
per cent of their time on administrative tasks, and of ward nurses spending an even
greater proportion of their time at nursing stations! Even student mental
nurses are lucky if they can achieve two hours contact time with clients during
a seven and a half hour shift.
At
all levels there was a resistance to new learning; anything new was taken as
criticism of current practice, an encroachment of and threat to someone‘s
territory, someone’s job, and the defensive response was always the same -
experience tells us it is not practical to change (and it costs too much). And
besides, our clients are different than the model suggests and won’t respond!
Consultation,
and then implementation, was placed in the hands of managers who had first trained
as nurses many years before, often espousing a version of Recovery learnt from
reading policy documents rather than practice, to younger workers who daily met
with clients and were more in touch with their circumstances. There were a
number of ‘team leaders’ who bonded as students whilst ‘necking and decking’ in
the old asylums who appeared to undergo weekend conversions to the Recovery
approach. Much organisational change was put on hold whilst they were trained-up.
There
is a sense in which mental health workers are more risk averse than their
clients. I sat for eighteen months or so, on a DPT implementation committee for
my local area. After an initial false start however, an outsider was appointed
who didn’t carry the baggage of longer serving employees. However she was only appointed
on a one year contract and much of what she did was subject to both conscious
and unconscious obstruction – many simply did not appreciate that the Recovery
approach, whatever its weaknesses, nonetheless was a challenge to the
appropriateness of established practice and required a change in personal
conduct.
Committees
are often the death of change, the quasi-democratic structure of NHS management
based on professional group demarcations plus some user consultation gives all
interested parties their own five minutes, but when interests conflict, as they
must, the chair can reinforce the status quo whenever they choose. Authority in
hierarchy, rarely trumps professional demarcation and autonomy in practice.
Equally,
in the bureaucracy of mental health, where there is no clearly defined product
or outcome, then it is the amount of visible activity which is used as a
substitute for real achievement, success being measured by the size of a budget
and the number of staff employed.
Strangely
mental health organisations often operate in an information vacuum, this may
strike the outsider as incomprehensible since there has never been a period
when so much mental health information is so easily available, yet many
professionals are ignorant of it. In order for one professional group to assume
expertise in one particular area requires seeding authority to other groups in
other areas. This can be a disaster if there are no generalists left, how many
front line mental health workers, pursuing a Recovery approach or otherwise,
know that experimental psychology, neuroscience and forensic behavioural
science have made much of their work irrelevant and or potentially damaging to
their clients?
One
simple training initiative proposed by myself to allow those less experienced
in Recovery practice, though formally more senior, to see Recovery in practice
(me as client in interaction with an experienced Recovery worker) once a week
for forty-five minutes during a lunchtime at a local community mental health
centre was brushed aside as being only appropriate in a formal training
setting, run by trainers on official ‘away-days’, in other words costing
thousands of pounds instead of nothing at all. In such small ways does the NHS
forever expand, create needless jobs and financially become a bottomless pit.
In
recent years most service user participants have become explicitly incorporated into the hierarchy and bureaucracy
of DPT; as trainers on courses for clients rather than staff, as peer
supporters supervised by nurses - which becomes absurd since the whole point of
a peer supporter is that they do something a nurse cannot do, nor understand in
the fullest sense. Managers want the credibility of association with those with
‘lived experience’ without the need to fundamentally challenge their own
behaviour.
But
all this pales into insignificance alongside some of the larger absurdities.
The headquarters of DPT remains within the last local example of a Victorian asylum,
one of the ‘back wards’ has been used for many years as the showcase inpatient
Recovery unit where clients can stay for up to a year! Managers will tell you
they have been unable to do otherwise because of the way the building was
gifted to the Crown (for the expressed use of mental patients) way back in the
days of the formation of the NHS. But those senior managers, doctors and nurses
who push for a Recovery approach were not born and brought in Exeter. Digby and
Exminster hospitals may had been the long stay ‘bins’ from which your relatives
never returned, but Wonford House – the building in question - was the first
port of call for anyone taken off the streets, or from their homes. The
location, one word in fact, Dryden (as in Road/Lane/Clinic) was enough to
stigmatise anyone. Well over a million pounds must have been spent on Recovery
by now, but a lot more could have been done to aid the community, as well as
clients, by simply hiring a cheap suite of offices in the centre of the city.
Equally, the Trust had a free hand to develop a two hundred acre rural site a
few miles away on the coast, yet chose to take the Home Office’s money to build
a new secure hospital for the prison service.
Equally
it was the police service which insisted that the statuary provider finally do
something about providing a ‘place of safety’; a pilot scheme was initiated
(actually two rooms from an existing psychiatric ward), STR support laid on to
be alongside potential patients whilst they were being assessed and sure enough
the number of people actually admitted to hospital fell. After six months
however the money stopped and was diverted to pay for an extra approved mental
health professional (someone legally sanctioned to 'section' people). Now a couple
of years on a different scheme is being tried as an alternative to hospital,
but that’s prompted now by the shortage of beds.
It
was when someone within DPT said, ‘..it takes ten years to bring about real
organisational change’, that I knew it was time to absent myself from any
further involvement!
Conclusion
- the paradox of ‘control’
Now
the game has changed. DPT having attempted to manage change, rather than allow
it to evolve organically from the bottom-up, has seen what Recovery focused
care there was eroded by the external pressure of severe budgetary constraint.
The irony is that the Recovery approach only really costs money if you see it as
a top-down process of managing organisational change! CCT was also forced, late-in-the-day, to reduce the scale
of its activities due to a reluctance to compete for contracts. Recovery is on
hold.
In
day to day interactions between workers and clients the focus has become more
and more on the construction or reconstruction of an individual’s personal
story or emotional journey.
Some
people feel it is enough to vomit their personal distress over a keyboard, a
therapist or an audience; that others acceptance and validation is the
therapeutic goal. But that is not storytelling in the true sense, for there is
nothing necessarily useful in sharing for sharing’s sake, all it does is
attract the empathy of those who have been there too, who are equally
distressed. It offers nothing that makes it easier for the author or their
audience to get up tomorrow.
It
is now well established that each time we remember we update our memory within
the present context – what we are recalling from several years ago, is actually
the version we told ourselves a few weeks ago, the last time we recalled it! Your
carefully constructed personal story is always out of date. Much better to keep
a journal. Record a little regularly, then set aside. Going back to a journal
after a number of months or years gives a measure of change. The ‘making sense
of the world to yourself’ or ‘discovering what you’re thinking by writing’ is
of the moment, a process not of fixing, but of letting go.
Journals
take you back to a present moment, removing a large element of reconstruction,
illuminating what change has occurred, been forgotten, then occurred again –
all in a world of uncertainty where the resilience or robustness of a ‘personal
story’ is brittle and likely to collapse at any time.
Recovery
is based on an old existentialism as manifested in 1940’s humanist psychology,
updated with a 1980’s post-modern frame of reference. Large dosages of political
correctness, of rights and entitlements, but increasingly bureaucratised at the
same time as advocating social networking. There is certainly a phenomenon
which might be called Recoveryism, the assumption that the pursuit of a Recovery
approach is a virtue, in and of itself. An inward looking-ness, which hates
feedback as much as those traditional approaches it once criticised.
Tuesday, 27 July 2010
The answer... (updated 2023!)
What follows is an outrageous exercise in selecting half-quotes, which I’ve strung together into two paragraphs, all taken from the final chapter of Sue Blakemore’s The Meme Machine (see January post What are memes? Sue Blackmore explains) However they all appear in the order in which they were written, and I believe provide an accurate summary of the conclusion of the book. Indeed they are the passages and phrases that I have highlighted myself (in yellow!) on my own photocopy of the chapter which I carry in my satchel at all times.
‘..Only when we see a human being as a product of both natural and memetic selection can we bring all aspects of our lives together within one theoretical framework. ..Memes fight it out to get passed on into another brain or book or object, and in the process cultural and mental design comes about. ..There is no need to call on the creative ‘power of consciousness’, ..Free will, like the ‘self’ who has it, is an illusion. ..explanation adds nothing. It is just a story ..after the fact. ..all human actions, whether conscious or not, come from complex interactions between memes, genes and all their products, in complicated environments. ..by consciousness I mean subjectivity - what it’s like being me now. ..not a force, or a causal agent, that can make things happen. ..the most mindless and least conscious of our actions can be imitated just as easily as our most conscious ones. Cultural and social variation is guided by the replicators and their environment, ..new ideas came out of the combinations of the old. ..a combined product of the genes and memes playing out their competition in ..life. ..The creative achievements of human culture are the products of memetic evolution, ..selves can often do more harm than good, for creative acts often come about in a state of selflessness, or loss of self-consciousness, when the self seems to be out of the way. ..knowledge is a kind of adaptation. So is foresight. ..comes about by selection, only in this case it is selection between memes.’
‘..the ‘me’ that could do the selecting is itself a memetic construct ..The choices made will all be a product of my genetic and memetic history in a given environment, not of some separate self that can ‘have’ a life purpose and overrule the memes that make it up. ..there is no room for anyone or anything to jump into the evolutionary process and stop it, direct it, or do anything to it. ..and no one watching. ..how can ‘I’ live as though I do not exist, and who would be choosing to do so? ..concentrate on the present moment - all the time - letting go of any thoughts that come up. ..kind of ‘meme weeding’ ..in any moment there is no observable self. ..Ideas will come up but these are all past- and future-orientated; so let them go, come back to the present. Just notice what is happening. ..pay attention to everything equally. ..attention is always being manipulated by things outside yourself rather than controlled by you. ..and created you. ..there is no distinction between myself and the things happening. It is only when ‘I’ want something, respond to something, believe something, decide to do something, that ‘I’ suddenly appear. ..‘I’ in the middle - me in charge, me responsible, me suffering. ..Learning to pay attention to everything equally stops self-related memes from grabbing the attention ..waking from the meme dream. ..accept that the selection of genes and memes will determine the action ..just get out of the way and allow decisions to make themselves. ..it is odd to observe that actions happen whether or not ‘I’ will them. A great sense of freedom to let so many decisions alone. You do not have to try to do anything or agonise about any decision. ..letting the false self get out of the way, and the decisions make themselves ..the whole process seems to do itself. ..hope and desire are based on the idea of an inner self who must be kept happy ..meet them all with a refusal to get involved ..life really is possible without hope. ..people become more decisive rather than less. ..the selfplex ..it is there for the propagation of the memes that make it up. Its demolition allows more spontaneous and appropriate action. Clever thinking brains, installed with plenty of memes, are quite capable of making sound decisions without a selfplex messing them up. ..you stop inflicting your own desires on the world around you and on the people you meet. ..giving up the illusion of a self in control. ..guilt, shame, embarrassment, self-doubt, and fear of failure ebb away and I become, contrary to expectation, a better neighbour. ..When there is no selfplex, there is no concern about the future of my inner self - whether people like me or whether I did the right thing or not ..free to notice other people more. ..easy to see what another person needs, or how to act in a given situation, ..stopping all the harm we normally do, ..there is no one to rebel.’
..the question of course was; how does cultural and social evolution work?
‘..Only when we see a human being as a product of both natural and memetic selection can we bring all aspects of our lives together within one theoretical framework. ..Memes fight it out to get passed on into another brain or book or object, and in the process cultural and mental design comes about. ..There is no need to call on the creative ‘power of consciousness’, ..Free will, like the ‘self’ who has it, is an illusion. ..explanation adds nothing. It is just a story ..after the fact. ..all human actions, whether conscious or not, come from complex interactions between memes, genes and all their products, in complicated environments. ..by consciousness I mean subjectivity - what it’s like being me now. ..not a force, or a causal agent, that can make things happen. ..the most mindless and least conscious of our actions can be imitated just as easily as our most conscious ones. Cultural and social variation is guided by the replicators and their environment, ..new ideas came out of the combinations of the old. ..a combined product of the genes and memes playing out their competition in ..life. ..The creative achievements of human culture are the products of memetic evolution, ..selves can often do more harm than good, for creative acts often come about in a state of selflessness, or loss of self-consciousness, when the self seems to be out of the way. ..knowledge is a kind of adaptation. So is foresight. ..comes about by selection, only in this case it is selection between memes.’
‘..the ‘me’ that could do the selecting is itself a memetic construct ..The choices made will all be a product of my genetic and memetic history in a given environment, not of some separate self that can ‘have’ a life purpose and overrule the memes that make it up. ..there is no room for anyone or anything to jump into the evolutionary process and stop it, direct it, or do anything to it. ..and no one watching. ..how can ‘I’ live as though I do not exist, and who would be choosing to do so? ..concentrate on the present moment - all the time - letting go of any thoughts that come up. ..kind of ‘meme weeding’ ..in any moment there is no observable self. ..Ideas will come up but these are all past- and future-orientated; so let them go, come back to the present. Just notice what is happening. ..pay attention to everything equally. ..attention is always being manipulated by things outside yourself rather than controlled by you. ..and created you. ..there is no distinction between myself and the things happening. It is only when ‘I’ want something, respond to something, believe something, decide to do something, that ‘I’ suddenly appear. ..‘I’ in the middle - me in charge, me responsible, me suffering. ..Learning to pay attention to everything equally stops self-related memes from grabbing the attention ..waking from the meme dream. ..accept that the selection of genes and memes will determine the action ..just get out of the way and allow decisions to make themselves. ..it is odd to observe that actions happen whether or not ‘I’ will them. A great sense of freedom to let so many decisions alone. You do not have to try to do anything or agonise about any decision. ..letting the false self get out of the way, and the decisions make themselves ..the whole process seems to do itself. ..hope and desire are based on the idea of an inner self who must be kept happy ..meet them all with a refusal to get involved ..life really is possible without hope. ..people become more decisive rather than less. ..the selfplex ..it is there for the propagation of the memes that make it up. Its demolition allows more spontaneous and appropriate action. Clever thinking brains, installed with plenty of memes, are quite capable of making sound decisions without a selfplex messing them up. ..you stop inflicting your own desires on the world around you and on the people you meet. ..giving up the illusion of a self in control. ..guilt, shame, embarrassment, self-doubt, and fear of failure ebb away and I become, contrary to expectation, a better neighbour. ..When there is no selfplex, there is no concern about the future of my inner self - whether people like me or whether I did the right thing or not ..free to notice other people more. ..easy to see what another person needs, or how to act in a given situation, ..stopping all the harm we normally do, ..there is no one to rebel.’
..the question of course was; how does cultural and social evolution work?
Sunday, 13 June 2010
Walking Through Life - how mental distress is caught and taught
As a child you watched how parents or siblings walked and then you began to copy them. So it was with everything else you learnt, as peers and other adults entered your environment. Experience and learning are inseparable. The more you practice existing skills, the more you try to reproduce today, the world as it was yesterday. All learning consists of first imitating (copying or modelling) how others behave, then repeated practice (trial and error) - both mentally and physically - until you gain a skill. All behaviours are habits. And the only way to overcome an unwanted habit is to copy a better one from someone else. We are social animals with a social brain.
At some point you learnt to walk down the street and avoid eye contact with someone (the invitation to normal social interaction), if that became a habit, not just towards those you disliked for a reason, but a practice applied to the whole social world of others you acquired a mental 'illness'. The classic way of avoiding eye contact is to look down and away (a gesture normally reserved for the occasional experience of shame), but if you stare at the pavement for a lifetime - rather than naturally allowing the eyes to return to the horizon giving an automatic upright posture - then you become a physical cripple because of your social isolation.
Another form of isolation is when we look through people, being physically present but mentally somewhere else. But that leaves the person terribly exposed, you can't do two things at once - fantasise and be in the present moment. Very quickly others notice that your speech simply doesn't fit the situation. The so-called 'psychotic' person follows an erratic path and easily becomes disorientated because they are disorganised. Eventually, they too will look down and away.
Sometimes people come to believe that hanging-on to familiar, habitual, well understood, fears will keep them safe, not just from occasional real physical danger, but from other anxieties in everyday living. The desire to be in control too much - causes more isolation from others. But when you make eye contact with others, when you operate your body in the same way as someone else, you begin to have the same kinds of thoughts (though the content may be different). The desire to belong, which is in all of us, is rewarded.
(See previous posts on meditation, and physical therapy for the 'up' side of the story. The acquisition of new social skills and better habits will be discussed in future posts).
At some point you learnt to walk down the street and avoid eye contact with someone (the invitation to normal social interaction), if that became a habit, not just towards those you disliked for a reason, but a practice applied to the whole social world of others you acquired a mental 'illness'. The classic way of avoiding eye contact is to look down and away (a gesture normally reserved for the occasional experience of shame), but if you stare at the pavement for a lifetime - rather than naturally allowing the eyes to return to the horizon giving an automatic upright posture - then you become a physical cripple because of your social isolation.
Another form of isolation is when we look through people, being physically present but mentally somewhere else. But that leaves the person terribly exposed, you can't do two things at once - fantasise and be in the present moment. Very quickly others notice that your speech simply doesn't fit the situation. The so-called 'psychotic' person follows an erratic path and easily becomes disorientated because they are disorganised. Eventually, they too will look down and away.
Sometimes people come to believe that hanging-on to familiar, habitual, well understood, fears will keep them safe, not just from occasional real physical danger, but from other anxieties in everyday living. The desire to be in control too much - causes more isolation from others. But when you make eye contact with others, when you operate your body in the same way as someone else, you begin to have the same kinds of thoughts (though the content may be different). The desire to belong, which is in all of us, is rewarded.
(See previous posts on meditation, and physical therapy for the 'up' side of the story. The acquisition of new social skills and better habits will be discussed in future posts).
Saturday, 27 March 2010
Acceptance is the hardest 'skill' to learn
It’s a skill because it doesn’t come naturally.
I once asked a friend of mine who is a senior mental health worker, and almost universally liked by everyone: ‘Isn’t the idea of “unconditional positive regard” totally unrealistic - it implies you can like anyone who walks through the door?’ He then claimed that he did like almost every client. I think he was fooling himself, and what he meant with the benefit of hindsight, was that he came to like almost every client - that the more he understood someone the more he liked them.
Carl Rogers started it when he asserted the possibility of unconditional positive regard towards others, built on the idea of accepting oneself:
‘I find I am more effective when I can listen acceptantly to myself, and can be myself.’ (Roger 1967:17)
‘…the curious paradox is that when I accept myself as I am, then I change.’
‘If I can accept the fact that I am annoyed at or bored with this client or this student, then I am also much more likely to be able to accept his feelings in response.’ (p.18)
‘I have found it highly rewarding when I can accept another person.’ (p.20)
The post-war humanist perspective in psychology lost touch with the biology of the human animal - as indeed did the cognitive revolution that followed it. Anxiety should rise when meeting strangers or outsiders, they are a potential threat, you should be cautiously testing each other. We do have very strong first impressions; it is called intuition, and relies on fast emotional responses - it is what keeps us alive. The only question on first meeting someone is: ‘Do I feel safe with this person?’ So the effective helper knows that they must appear safe and non-threatening, but what if you don‘t feel that? We can all be aggressive and violent, if we need to be. It’s not a matter of accepting people as they are, it’s about creating useful encounters where mutual learning can take place and that depends on establishing a relationship of trust. Sometimes it can happen very fast if there is a mutual liking, if there isn’t then it will never happen.
When asked, people self-report that what makes the best first impression is a sense of ‘warmth’ and ‘competence’ in the other person ( www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=mixed-impressions ), but I think what they really mean is someone who is non-threatening and can deliver something they need. Because first impressions are emotional responses they have very little to do with what is actually said, more with how it is said and the rest of our non-verbal behaviour. We trust those emotions displayed through facial expression much more than the accepting words.
The client is present because they know there is something wrong with them, whether they state it or not, something that stops them functioning in the social world as they would wish. That is why they are seeking help, they’re not looking for acceptance but action, on the assumption that they are meeting with someone with skills and expertise.
But what of Rogers’ underlying point that accepting oneself and others as we are now, is in some sense a precondition of change? Wrong. The preconditions are self-awareness and a willingness to learn new things! And the speed at which it can be done depends on the rapport between the people involved.
One barrier to rapport (effective communication) is the myth that the helper can be accepting as part of their professional role, setting aside their personal feelings. This is obviously ridiculous because feelings always leak-out through facial expression and tone of voice. This first becomes apparent when a prospective helper is still a student and at some point becomes aware of a conflict between their developing intellectual understanding and their emotional response in a given situation. The trick is integrating the two. If I believe in the knowledge I have acquired then I must live that way, the mistake is thinking that one is work and the other a private concern. The answer comes in two parts, firstly in terms of organisation there has to be proper team working - teams purposefully constructed of different kinds of people with different skills, hence giving the client choice!
Secondly, any kind of therapy is the learning of new social and psychological skills and the helper is the model. Acceptance is the skill of tolerating what we cannot change. Now if either or both, client and worker have it in their heads that the client is suffering an illness for which there is no cure… Even the Recovery approach leaves the medical model in place, telling the client to expect occasional relapse. So often both client and worker set each other up to fail. But if your model is one of adaptation in a particular social environment you have two choices, neither of which require acceptance of anything. Either you change yourself (learn new skills) to fit the environment you find yourself in, or you move on and live in a new environment.
It is a belief in people‘s lack of capacity to change which makes acceptance, so unnatural as it is, such a hard skill to learn - requiring decades of practice by the helper!
(See also my post, The ‘therapeutic relationship’ explained - Jan 2010)
Rogers, C (1967) On Becoming a Person: A Therapist’s View of Psychotherapy (Constable: London)
I once asked a friend of mine who is a senior mental health worker, and almost universally liked by everyone: ‘Isn’t the idea of “unconditional positive regard” totally unrealistic - it implies you can like anyone who walks through the door?’ He then claimed that he did like almost every client. I think he was fooling himself, and what he meant with the benefit of hindsight, was that he came to like almost every client - that the more he understood someone the more he liked them.
Carl Rogers started it when he asserted the possibility of unconditional positive regard towards others, built on the idea of accepting oneself:
‘I find I am more effective when I can listen acceptantly to myself, and can be myself.’ (Roger 1967:17)
‘…the curious paradox is that when I accept myself as I am, then I change.’
‘If I can accept the fact that I am annoyed at or bored with this client or this student, then I am also much more likely to be able to accept his feelings in response.’ (p.18)
‘I have found it highly rewarding when I can accept another person.’ (p.20)
The post-war humanist perspective in psychology lost touch with the biology of the human animal - as indeed did the cognitive revolution that followed it. Anxiety should rise when meeting strangers or outsiders, they are a potential threat, you should be cautiously testing each other. We do have very strong first impressions; it is called intuition, and relies on fast emotional responses - it is what keeps us alive. The only question on first meeting someone is: ‘Do I feel safe with this person?’ So the effective helper knows that they must appear safe and non-threatening, but what if you don‘t feel that? We can all be aggressive and violent, if we need to be. It’s not a matter of accepting people as they are, it’s about creating useful encounters where mutual learning can take place and that depends on establishing a relationship of trust. Sometimes it can happen very fast if there is a mutual liking, if there isn’t then it will never happen.
When asked, people self-report that what makes the best first impression is a sense of ‘warmth’ and ‘competence’ in the other person ( www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=mixed-impressions ), but I think what they really mean is someone who is non-threatening and can deliver something they need. Because first impressions are emotional responses they have very little to do with what is actually said, more with how it is said and the rest of our non-verbal behaviour. We trust those emotions displayed through facial expression much more than the accepting words.
The client is present because they know there is something wrong with them, whether they state it or not, something that stops them functioning in the social world as they would wish. That is why they are seeking help, they’re not looking for acceptance but action, on the assumption that they are meeting with someone with skills and expertise.
But what of Rogers’ underlying point that accepting oneself and others as we are now, is in some sense a precondition of change? Wrong. The preconditions are self-awareness and a willingness to learn new things! And the speed at which it can be done depends on the rapport between the people involved.
One barrier to rapport (effective communication) is the myth that the helper can be accepting as part of their professional role, setting aside their personal feelings. This is obviously ridiculous because feelings always leak-out through facial expression and tone of voice. This first becomes apparent when a prospective helper is still a student and at some point becomes aware of a conflict between their developing intellectual understanding and their emotional response in a given situation. The trick is integrating the two. If I believe in the knowledge I have acquired then I must live that way, the mistake is thinking that one is work and the other a private concern. The answer comes in two parts, firstly in terms of organisation there has to be proper team working - teams purposefully constructed of different kinds of people with different skills, hence giving the client choice!
Secondly, any kind of therapy is the learning of new social and psychological skills and the helper is the model. Acceptance is the skill of tolerating what we cannot change. Now if either or both, client and worker have it in their heads that the client is suffering an illness for which there is no cure… Even the Recovery approach leaves the medical model in place, telling the client to expect occasional relapse. So often both client and worker set each other up to fail. But if your model is one of adaptation in a particular social environment you have two choices, neither of which require acceptance of anything. Either you change yourself (learn new skills) to fit the environment you find yourself in, or you move on and live in a new environment.
It is a belief in people‘s lack of capacity to change which makes acceptance, so unnatural as it is, such a hard skill to learn - requiring decades of practice by the helper!
(See also my post, The ‘therapeutic relationship’ explained - Jan 2010)
Rogers, C (1967) On Becoming a Person: A Therapist’s View of Psychotherapy (Constable: London)
Sunday, 14 February 2010
Minimum Qualifications (for helpers and supporters)
If I feel I need help.
If I can ask for help.
If I can lift the phone.
If I can open my door to you, or get through your door, or meet you in a public place.
Then
Can I feel safe with you?
Can I talk to you?
Are there words to describe my feelings and thoughts?
Can you see how I feel?
Can I trust you (does what you say, match the way you act)?
Can you show some understanding?
Can you do something today, that will allow me to act tomorrow (hope)?
Are we both in the present moment?
If I can ask for help.
If I can lift the phone.
If I can open my door to you, or get through your door, or meet you in a public place.
Then
Can I feel safe with you?
Can I talk to you?
Are there words to describe my feelings and thoughts?
Can you see how I feel?
Can I trust you (does what you say, match the way you act)?
Can you show some understanding?
Can you do something today, that will allow me to act tomorrow (hope)?
Are we both in the present moment?
Tuesday, 2 February 2010
It's Groundhog Day - again!

Groundhog Day (1993) director Harold Ramis, based on a story by Danny Rubin, staring Bill Murray and Andie MacDowell. Murray plays Phil Connors an egocentric Pittsburgh TV weatherman who, during a hated assignment covering the annual Groundhog Day event in Punxsutawney on the 2nd February, finds himself repeating the same day over and over again…
Over the last ten years or so I’ve got into the habit of re-watching this movie on the 2nd February, it reminds me of what my life has felt like in times past, and could become again, if I get too preoccupied with myself.
It’s one of those movies which leads audiences to endlessly speculate on it’s meaning. Perhaps the dominant view is that it’s about an individual over concerned with ‘self’, leading to unpleasant situations that continually repeat, until he can transcend them and let go - putting other people rather than himself at the centre of his universe. A tale of self-improvement that looks outward, rather than being focused on one’s own need to be ‘in control’. It’s also a hilarious comedy!
Ryan Gilbey writing in The Observer 1.2.04:
‘While Groundhog Day is undeniably charming, it shares a certain stubbornness of purpose with its star. From the moment Rubin typed the first line of his first draft, he resolved to withhold all explanations about how Connors came to be stuck in a time-loop. Co-written and directed by Harry Ramis, the finished film exploits the witty device of a narrative that achieves momentum without moving forward. Rubin refused to surrender the enigma at the movie's core; the absence of narrative exposition remains the most audacious element of Groundhog Day, not to mention one of the most daring ellipses in Hollywood cinema.’
…As well as making its impact on cinema and language, Groundhog Day has exerted a strong influence on religious thinking. Rubin and Ramis continue to receive letters congratulating them on a positive representation of Buddhism. Presumably they file such correspondence alongside similar messages in which the film is claimed by Jesuit priests, rabbis, and followers of the Chinese spiritual movement Falun Dafa, aka Falun Gong. All the letters are characterised by a singleminded belief that the movie endorses the author's faith. 'At first, I would get mail saying, "You must be a Christian, because the movie so beautifully expresses Christian belief,"'Ramis said recently. 'Then rabbis started calling, saying they were preaching the film as their next sermon.'
Roger Ebert writing in the Chicago Sun 30.1.05:
‘Tomorrow and tomorrow and tomorrow, in his case, doesn't creep in at its petty pace from day to day, but gets stuck like a broken record. After the third or fourth day, the enormity of his predicament is forced upon him. He is free to change what he says and does from one Feb. 2 to the next, but it will always be Feb. 2 for everyone else in the world, and he will always start from the same place. They will repeat themselves unless he changes the script, but tomorrow they will have forgotten their new lines and be back to the first draft of Feb. 2.
...One night in a bowling alley, sitting at the bar, he says almost to himself: “What would you do if you were stuck in one place, and everything that you did was the same, and nothing mattered?” The sad sack next to him at the bar overhears him and answers: “That about sums it up for me.” Slowly, inexpertly, Phil begins to learn from his trial runs through Feb. 2'.
Saturday, 16 January 2010
Physical therapy for mental health
The brain and body are so intimately connected it makes little sense to separate them when conceptualising mental health. The appropriate ‘treatment’ for mental health problems may well be a physical one. When in the presence of someone who is ‘psychotic’, you probably won’t understand their speech content - why not just watch the body?
Tone and rhythm of speech, facial expression, eye and head movement, gestures, body posture and body movement. What would a physiotherapist see? Suppose on encountering someone for the first time you ignore the apparent mental problems; offer just physical relaxation techniques, enforce a regular but limited sleep pattern, strictly control diet and everything else they put in their bodies - and wait. Introduce mindfulness techniques - for better anxiety and stress management, for greater mental awareness as well as physical relaxation. Then what you are left with is someone with communication problems! A blocked ability to empathise, and a limited ‘theory of mind’.
Reintroduce the most powerful communication tool of all - touch! So they can learn, or more often relearn to be intimate with others - healthy others like you. You offer intimacy. You teach them to dance, to play table tennis and pool, for hour after hour - to gain ‘balance’ (physical coordination) and the ability to ‘navigate’ (in space and time) in that social landscape of others. You provide daily massage, so the client cannot deny the world of others. On such a foundation clients can start to learn again. Acute psychiatric units could be reorganised to provide physical not mental care, for the first week to ten days of any admission, only a client's physical signs and symptoms of ill health would be treated.
A cold body is physically and mentally stressed, warmth is relaxation - too hot and you are anxious. The body and mind feedback on each other. Health in body and mind are the same thing. The source of health lies in natural environments - just as nothing in nature can be ugly, only the man-made! We evolved to be outside and on our feet all day, with our eyes resting naturally on the horizon - catching the sun. Depression is entombing yourself all day, with a slumped body posture and nothing but artificial light, consuming more calories that you use up. It’s about having a fixed territory, being stuck in one place and one time, and defending it in both a mental and physical sense. Mental wellbeing is about being happy with movement and change.
It is not a sign of progress that the modern world is able to offer mental health care! It is offered because the need has developed since we started transforming our natural habits and ways of living. Anxiety and the heightened awareness that goes with it, is the normal response to perceived danger - the natural reaction is either fight, flight or to remain motionless (the predator notices first the moving object). In the absence of real danger, anxiety should rapidly fall away. It is normal to fear ‘outsiders’ or ‘strangers’. Anxiety is part way on the continuum from happiness (loss of self-consciousness) to intense fear. Misplaced fear of others in the modern world, or the inability to attribute fear to the right people (or less often other things in the environment) is what makes others appear as permanent strangers, outsiders or simply mad.
Most communication is non-verbal, and cannot be spoken or written down - but can be physically observed and physically responded to. The meaning of any communication is the message received. You can only be conscious of a tiny fraction of what your brain is doing in any one moment - including thoughts and emotions. You can only ‘know’ your character by what you put in your body, and by the kind of people you spend your time with. The best diet for physical and mental health is a pre-agricultural one; the absence of refined sugars, cultivated and ground grains, domesticated animal meat and milk. The inability to navigate with sight, sound, touch, smell and taste, is a fundamental element of what some call psychosis. A lack of balance, not being able to let the eyes rest naturally on the horizon, which is obscured by the built environment, and feel the natural contours below one’s feet, equally obliterated in the modern world, shows in the long term mental as well as physical ‘crippling’ of the body!
Friday, 15 January 2010
Meditation techniques for mental health
Meditation is about being more physically relaxed at the same time as gaining greater mental awareness - throughout the day and with your eyes open! It’s about being in the present moment and therefore more grounded in reality. Despite the rather naive acceptance by some psychiatric authorities of mystical claims about ‘altered states of consciousness’; misunderstanding over an apparent connection with trance, dream like states and psychosis; and the timid approval by the NHS of just one aspect of meditation known as Mindfulness (sometimes referred to as ‘kitchen-sink meditation’) - it is, once stripped of its religious elements, the most important tool I have against madness. It’s the best anti-psychotic there is.
Untangling the myth however is not easy, you need to ‘suspend your disbelief’ and consider for a moment that the meditator is more in touch with reality than you are. You may imagine someone on a mountainside, eyes closed in the lotus position, but the real practitioners may be passing you in the street unnoticed - they blend into the social landscape because they are in the here and now, whilst you are preoccupied with your own thoughts. Your conscious thoughts can only be about the past or future, in the present you only have your senses with which to literally ‘feel’ your way around. Realise your emotions come from the data your senses are giving you now - then you’ll have it! It’s a shock, like waking up from a dream, you are back in the real world for the first time since - when? Suddenly self-consciousness, anxiety and fear can be put to their proper use; of spotting the occasional occurrence of real danger. You can get back to the proper use of your time, finding activities that match your skills and can become absorbed in, achieving some degree of ‘flow’, that sense of happiness that comes from the loss of self-consciousness - something we all felt in childhood play.
The first ‘pay off’ from meditation is the awareness of where you feel fear in your body, what in the environment has triggered or cued your brain to remember some past unpleasant association. It may be an unwelcome series of sensations to begin with, but it soon becomes a useful revelation. This is followed by learning to let go of unwanted thoughts and feelings about the past and future. In the process you can stare life in the face - as it is now.
One of the things meditation tackles well is our ‘illusion of self-control’. We like to think we are consciously in control of ourselves all the time. We distrust our basic, spontaneous impulsive actions. We must be constantly choosing all the time as free independent individuals. As a result we have become acutely self-conscious. Yet there is only so much we can keep at the forefront of our minds at any one time. We come to consider it a failure or lapse in our own standards when we inevitably end up following the impulses of biology, and the learning we unconsciously achieved earlier in our lives. Meditation, by placing us back in the present moment and allowing us to feel what cues us, what stimulates our senses, shows us just how unnecessary the time and trouble we spent on worrying about decisions really was. Decisions are all about an unpredictable future over which we can exert little control. However, we can learn to trust our own brains to get on with it, become grounded in the environment of the present, reconnected to the social world of others, and just be.
Objectives
- to concentrate on the present moment all the time; let go of any thoughts that come up (knowing they can only be about the past or future), know too that in any one moment there is no observable ‘self’; to notice what is happening (not a series of events but continuous change), to pay equal attention to all that can be seen and therefore know what habitually cues you to feel or respond in a particular way (your attention, reactions, emotions, and the ‘story’ you tell yourself about who you are) - and so ultimately realise that it is the actions of others that is creating you.
- to understand that the ‘I’ or ‘me’ that appears when you want something is an obstacle to your sense of wellbeing; to allow decisions to make themselves (unconsciously) since the conscious self is not in control and actions happen whether or not you will them - sense the freedom that comes from knowing you don’t have to try to do anything!
- to refuse to get involved in desires and hopes (about an unknowable future), to know that it is quite possible to live without hope (now is all there is), that in the world of the present you can stop inflicting your desires on others, stop the harm we often do and be able to notice others more.
Finding A Focus
At the core of meditation is the ability to focus on something; whether it be within the body, an external object or a mental image. Focus is not concentration as such, but a fixed point of reference, something you always come back to. A fixed point, baseline or benchmark from which you can navigate your mental interpretation of the physical world. Physical relaxation must come first and the easiest way in is to focus on the breath - not control it, just ‘watch’ it. Once relaxed you can begin to focus away from yourself towards the environment you find yourself in. In a natural environment it makes sense to let your gaze rest on the horizon and make that your focus. Whether we like it or not our attention will be constantly distracted by whatever our senses pick up from the environment and the internal thoughts and feelings prompted by those cues. The ‘trick’ is to always come back to the focus, again and again. You acknowledge the thought or perception, and let it go in the act of always returning to the focus. When truly focused, for however shorter time that may be, you think of nothing else. However the choice of focus at any one time does need to be something that holds your interest - something you enjoy exploring. Good focusing is a joy, as you begin to learn to let go you can start to recapture that childhood sensing and feeling, which never required conscious thought and has a fascination all of it’s own.
Balance
There is however a need to create a balance, between physical relaxation (too much of which leads to sleep) and greater mental awareness (which if not matched with the right degree of relaxation, may provoke a degree of anxiety about ‘what’s going on’ and increase self-consciousness). Stress is not an external force, but occurs within the body, our attention is usually directed outwards so we don’t recognise it in our bodies. In the process of physically relaxing we can identify stress and let it go; so our increasing awareness becomes a tool with which to see the world rather than a product of anxiety that may cause us to turn away.
Relaxation
If the first requirement is physical relaxation, and that is dependant on focused breathing, then an unrestricted diaphragm is a precondition of meditation - it is not the choice of posture itself that matters, but how you hold yourself in it. You can meditate whilst sitting, lying down or walking. The breath naturally changes throughout the day and from minute to minute, if you can learn to watch it and not seek to control it, you notice how it automatically adjusts itself. After meditating for a while you realise it was your conscious attempts to control it that caused the problems in the first place. Unrestricted breathing then allows you to ‘listen’ to the body. Normally when we relax our minds have a tendency to wander, to fantasise or free associate, leading to sleep. Meditation usually has the opposite intention, beginning with the kind of self-knowledge that arises from a greater awareness of the body. You can literally feel mental stress as physical pain - as you begin to relax. Much mental distress is a shutting-off of awareness, of stopping feeling. Becoming more aware of the body begins to put you back in ‘touch’! Much of the tension in our bodies is an attempt to suppress unacceptable emotional responses. The technique known as a ‘body scan’ starts with an awareness of the breath, followed by deliberately focusing bit by bit on every area of the body, identifying tension, gently flexing the muscles, at the same time as noticing the thoughts and feelings that arise. And in the act of physically letting go, it’s a shock to realise just how much mental preoccupation seems to float away. Fear, anger, sorrow and desire all disappear when we are truly relaxed.
Meditating for sleep is different, with the eyes closed you may wish to initially focus on the breath, and body scan. But you shouldn’t seek greater awareness nor be tempted to move on and fantasise in a controlled, ‘story making’ way. Rather think of how dreams are when you’re asleep - less coherent, more a free association of thoughts. One technique is to explore a single visual image rather than imaging a movie.
The link between mental and physical relaxation becomes obvious when you see what great physical performers can do, and realise they could never do what they do unless they were relaxed in a holistic sense. But an even greater revelation comes when you see and hear those same people interviewed! If you want exemplary examples of ‘mental health’ look to the great dancers.
Awareness
Many people equate being alert with conscious thinking. But we can only be conscious of a very small amount of the brain’s activity at any one time and much of it we are never aware of. And we don’t need to be. What is useful is to educate ourselves from time to time about those things that habitually cue us to behave in a certain way. Not so much in order to change, but to stop ‘beating ourselves up’ over those things we have consciously decided should not be part of our self, our ‘I’ or ‘me’. Indeed with a lot of practice you can have consciousness, but no consciousness of self - just awareness!
Mindfulness is a basic technique to help you move from motionless meditation at an allotted time, to incorporating it into what should be continuous movement throughout the day. It’s about focusing on, and paying close attention to the detail of what we are doing in any given moment. Being very aware of the sights, sounds, smells, tastes and textures of the moment, becoming awake and tranquil by focusing intently on minute details. (There are obvious parallels here with being absorbed in the physical practice of a skill, but without the prescribed outcome). When eating just eat, when walking just walk. Walking is a good way to face each day a fresh, when you walk you ‘own’ nothing, you’re in constant movement and there is nothing but change around you, it feels natural to be nomadic - or it should do!
Mentally letting go again and again, brings greater awareness in the hear and now. It is the greatest reward of meditation to be suddenly flooded with insight, an intense feeling or a change of mood. To wonder where it came from, stop, look around, and then be amazed a second time to realise what cued that change. Understanding, and acceptance, of how things just are - in the same moment. And then to let go again. To borrow from Wordsworth: ‘Surprised by joy - impatient as the Wind …’. You lose nothing by letting go of good, as well as bad thoughts and feelings, because as you change, the ones that are useful and real will come back time and time again. Equally tranquillity comes not from changing the world, but from allowing the moments of emotional pain to die a natural death. Sometimes we don’t want to let go of our worries and fantasies, the conflicts that preoccupy us, they become part of our identity and maintain the world as it is, giving the illusion of self-control - the feeling that we can predict the future. But if we can be relaxed and aware in the present, all that falls away - we forget what used to preoccupy us.
When out and about the focus may switch from the breath to a visual object, a fixed point for navigation, but equally there is visualisation, an imagined image for still periods, usually with the eyes closed. But then there are transition states too, for example, ‘body asleep, mind awake’ which can have a better quality than sleep alone. You gain the benefit of an asleep body, but the mind, rather than having the chaos and illogical thoughts of dreaming, stays clear and focused.
And there are the times when it doesn’t matter if what we are sensing, tasting, touching with our bodies is pleasant or not! You just don’t feel the need to explain, understand, or solve, but simply watch and feel - then the realisation of the ‘right thing to do’ will occur at the time when it is appropriate to act. If we are open to the world, not preoccupied with ourselves, then our instinctive responses (which we have been taught to mistrust or contain) will fit the facts and we just feel the appropriate response in a given situation.
To Be More ‘Grounded’
Once grounded, we change and move on automatically. A connectedness to the physical world around us should be our moment to moment preoccupation. We cannot see others in our environment as they are, without it. When we are not preoccupied with ourselves, then we can see the needs of others. And it is in this state that we can approach an understanding of what may be the true basis of what is called spirituality or religious experience. Making others, and or, other things, rather than oneself, the central focus of our lives, allowing transcendent experiences - going beyond our usually limited perception of others. But it is equally valid to assert that in the past there must have been a time when we were all very effective at meditation. That in some sense it must be a natural state, for it is hard to imagine our hunter-gatherer ancestors being able to survive without such skills. Think of hunting, of long hours on one’s feet, of the constant gentle movements needed to pick up a trail, to track and stalk, feel movement in the air, the physical coordination, the ability to navigate, feel the sudden stress of real danger, but be able to let go when it passes, the need for so much stillness, and the quick flowing response. And afterwards, to squat for a while under a tree, to be within the only real temple there is - not enclosed by the buttressing of the branches, but open to the vaulting of the sky beyond. Later, the making of fire - the focus of community and collective narrative.
'To see a world in a grain of sand
And a heaven in a wild flower
Hold infinity in the palm of your hand
And eternity in an hour.'
William Blake 1757-1827: ‘Auguries of Innocence’ (c.1803)
That might well serve as a description of the potential of meditation and truly being in the moment. And Blake of course, experienced visual hallucinations from early childhood onwards. Meditation is a discipline that takes time and effort; though the more competent one becomes the more effortless it feels! Nonetheless like any set of skills, if you don’t practice then you lose them. It’s often when you feel at your lousiest, and have to ‘try’ the hardest that the most rewarding meditations follow. It is not unusual to suddenly feel worse as you relax and become more aware - you realise what’s been going on! This is the crucial moment to learn to continue meditating and not turn away - it is when the benefits really begin. At its best meditation gives a series of ongoing, ever deepening natural ‘highs’ based solely on increasing awareness of the fascination of the world around you. But don’t become a ‘bliss junkie’; stuck in a particular form of meditation, confined by time, place and routine or ritual - with a fixed set of beliefs about what is happening to you and your state of mind, seeking a continuous high, but effectively isolated from the rest of the world.
Meditation offers greater enjoyment of the sense world, deeper more varied emotional experiences and a sense of there being enough time. It feels like life with the ‘blinkers’ off, of a mental fog having lifted, in which we no longer fantasise - but then you catch yourself losing the focus again! But that’s as it should be, when navigating your way around a world of continuous change. Scientists and researchers in search of an ‘evidence base’ for meditation may object that whilst you can demonstrate a link with physical relaxation, the idea of greater mental awareness is not amenable to experimentation. Perhaps they are looking in the wrong place. I would wish to argue that it is the heightened awareness that comes with sudden stress or anxiety, and which to some extent has been measured, which through the discipline of meditation, is being harnessed by an individual who nonetheless remains physically relaxed.
Catch Tomorrow Now
Can you stop?
Let go of thoughts and feelings
Of the past and future
And just be in the present moment.
Now is all there is.
Reattach your emotions to your senses
In the real physical world of the present.
Notice what cues your thoughts now
Acknowledge them and let them go
Good or bad.
Allow yourself to feel the bad when it happens
Then it passes quickly.
Allow yourself to be ‘surprised by joy’
And let go those feelings too.
Knowing they will return unbidden.
Think of yourself as having no fixed self.
Able to construct a self anew every day
Attentive to others, unconcern for an ‘I’ or a ‘me’.
Aware of the others who make you what you are.
You learn most by imitation.
You only remain fixed
When you remake yourself today
As you were yesterday.
You imagine the past must persist into the future
But only because you reproduce it afresh everyday.
Don’t look forward or back, but around.
Seek to be more relaxed and aware.
Absorb what’s around you
And catch tomorrow now!
The Rules
Can you stop?
Let go of the past and future - again and again
Be in the present moment
Pay equal attention to everything
Notice in the moment what cues your thoughts and emotions
Now is all there is
Let decisions make themselves
Refuse to get involved in hopes and expectations
Physically relax yourself continuously
Always have a focus
Catch Tomorrow Now - part 2
Can you replace your assumptions about others,
With curiosity and fascination?
And can you unlearn as you let go?
Your routines should be made to work for you,
Habits should be unconscious,
Leaving you free to notice other things.
There is no such thing as a mistake, only new learning.
And the meaning of any communication,
Is always the message received.
Every thought comes with an emotion attached
And rationalising is just a way,
Of putting emotions on hold!
Experiences just make you feel good or bad,
Meanings become attached afterwards;
And meanings never started anything!
Motivation for action can only come,
From an emotional attachment to others.
But it’s a misplaced fear of others,
That is the consequence of mental disorder!
Thursday, 14 January 2010
Psychiatrists - they don't know, they don't know!
Encounters with mental health workers still tend to take place in locations and contexts of their choosing. They see us when we are unwell, with the tacit agreement that we will talk about what distresses us and find difficult to articulate - not about those areas of our lives where we have demonstrable skills and competences. Even at the height of a crises they are alongside us for at most an hour out of every twenty-four. But as a peer, I may have been talking to the client before they meet with a worker, and again later in the day, know more about that person’s daily life than the worker, and sometimes find myself intentionally trying to undo their work. The ‘trap of the consulting room’ can lead the worker to imagine their training, delivered in a controlled environment, allows them to see client’s problems clearly, and their therapeutic responses as having an impact quite out of proportion with reality. Equally there is the assumption that the motivation to act, in a routine or novel way, is intrinsic to the individual. But the uncomfortable fact is that it is the behaviour of the worker when interacting with the client, rather than the prescribed model or approach pursued, which will or will not, lead to a rapport that may allow a positive outcome for the few weeks or months the relationship lasts.
The mental health professional works only with that part of the client’s ‘personal story’ they feel able to share with this relative stranger, who in their turn is even less inclined to ‘self-disclose’, adding to the existing power imbalance. The imagined ‘client centred-ness’ of their approach may well leave the service user ready to act on a specific issue - the previewed mental health problem - only to find its implementation leaves them exposed to a cascade of social consequences, requiring many more changes than either they or the worker have begun to contemplate. The individualism in nearly all approaches to mental health ignores our social nature and emphasises cognitive tools rather than the emotional foundations of human action. But when a form of counselling works, it is because the client has come to know and trust the worker enough to find their advice credible (and it is a process of advocacy about better ways to live) based on the degree to which the worker embodies what they assert. The client then acts as much for the worker as for themselves. The only problem is the worker is about to ‘ditch them’ - not because the relationship was a failure, but because it was a success!
Despite being involved in Involvement (participating in the giving of feedback to services, and the training of staff) for the last four years or so, it was only six months ago that myself and others got an opportunity to meet with a group of psychiatrists - and that session took over two years to set up. As the reader might imagine they were less than forthcoming, but one thing they seemed clear about, they were confident that when they see us, they see us the way we really are!
Back in 2007 I penned the following under the title A Few Of The Things A Psychiatrist Should Know - by a Service User, it seems they all still apply!
1/ that to ‘suspend your disbelief’ brings rewards; time spent with the same client when they are well, in addition to when they are distressed, in hospital and in the community, outside the atmosphere of the consulting room and the ward, is the only way to ‘see’ what ‘illness’ might be.
2/ all clients have difficultly explaining to themselves the strange things that have been happening to them, their thoughts and feelings - let alone finding the language to explain them to others. But, though they may be ‘inarticulate’ about their madness, they may not be about other areas of their lives.
3/ whatever the causes of mental distress/disorder/illness, the principal consequence is a ‘misplaced fear of others’, and a subsequent inability to make new and lasting personal relationships, leading to emotional isolation.
4/ despite the above, and often as the result of long experience, a client’s ‘fear of madness’ is probably less than yours!
5/ the client’s need is not for longer consultations, but to be seen by the same doctor over an extended period of time; by the same person in the hospital as in the community - how else can trust be established and the doctor acquire what he/she needs most - accurate information.
6/ what is needed is communication skills, don’t waste time trying to empathise with or ‘get inside the head’ of the client, just try to build a rapport; whereby they can tell you what they think it is important, and you can get the information you need.
7/ clients are afraid, if they don’t feel safe they will appear in worse shape than they really are, and not tell you anything.
8/ the most common complaint of clients is ‘why is this person asking irrelevant questions?’ Unless you can address their concerns, and demonstrate the relevance of yours, you get nowhere.
9/ the fastest way to improve someone’s mental health is to re-establish a regular sleep pattern, healthy diet, daily exercise plus learning to physically relax.
10/ very subtle changes in medication make a real difference to side effects, degrees of sedation and therefore compliance!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






